Mandelbrot set image very small MohammedAmin.com
Serious writing for
serious readers
Follow @Mohammed_Amin
Join my
email list

Search this site

Custom Search
Tap here for MENU

To perform Hajj more than once is a selfish act

Most Muslims will never be able to perform Hajj due to space constraints. If you go twice, you are depriving someone else of their only Hajj.

Posted 26 August 2018

Earlier today, I delivered my 43rd "Thought for the Week" broadcast on BBC Radio Manchester.

Until 24 September, you can listen to me delivering the "Thought for the Week" on the BBC iPlayer at this link. Listen from 2:37:00; I am on for about 10 minutes.

After reading my "Thought for the Week", I also discuss the following Sunday newspaper stories with the presenter Mike Shaft.

  1. "Apathy and Anger greet Pope" from the Sunday Times. Ireland has changed dramatically since Pope John Paul 2's visit in 1979, and the Roman Catholic Church has a much smaller role in public life. I discuss the implications for Irish reunification.
  2. "Salah Strike Sinks Seagulls" from the Sunday Times Sports section. Mo Salah has made a major difference to the way Muslims are seen in Liverpool and around the country.
  3. "Ladies Man Abu Hamza Plunged Hook, Line and Sinker into Soho Sleaze" from the Sunday Times. When someone leading a bad life "gets religion" it can be good, or it can be very dangerous.
  4. My selection for best picture was Stormy Daniels in the Sunday Mirror. I was struck by the strength of character revealed by the photograph.

As it was Eid al-Adha last week, I decided to share something I have been thinking about for many years.

Capacity constraints at Mecca mean that most Muslims will never be able to perform Hajj. Worse still, if you go on Hajj more than once, you are depriving some unknown person of the chance to perform Hajj once in their lifetime. In my view, performing multiple Hajj's is not virtuous but is instead selfish.

Thought for the week

Last week Muslims celebrated the festival of Eid al-Adha. This festival comes immediately after the Hajj, the pilgrimage to Mecca which every Muslim should do once in their lifetime if they are physically able and can afford it.

My wife and I went on Hajj in 2002. Looking back over the last 16 years, it has been a life changing experience.

The sheer size of the Hajj, around 3 million pilgrims in a small area of land in and around Mecca is mind blowing. I have been thinking about the numbers involved. 3 million pilgrims is a big number, but there are around 1.5 billion Muslims in the world. That means  the average Muslim would need to wait for 500 years to get their turn for Hajj.

This sobering calculation tells me that most Muslims will never be able to go on Hajj. There simply isn’t enough physical capacity around Mecca.

Saudi Arabia sets Hajj quotas for many countries. For the UK, there is no quota, but you have to wait five years before going again. That still allows many British Muslims to go on Hajj several times.

Having been on Hajj, I can understand why people want to go again. Most importantly, if you go on Hajj, your sins are supposed to be forgiven. However, I look at it a different way. If you go on Hajj a second time, you are taking up a space that would have been somebody else’s only time on Hajj.

My question is: “If you go on Hajj a second time, is that a good deed, or are you being selfish?

Supplemental comment

Hajj can only be performed on one specific date in the Islamic calendar. Those are the days 8 - 12 in the month of Dhu al-Hijjah, which is the last month of the Islamic year.

During the rest of the year, except when the facilities are closed, one can visit Mecca and perform Umrah. There are specific religious rites associated with Umrah, and performing Umrah has religious merits. However it is not obligatory for Muslims, and does not replace the performance of Hajj which is a religious duty for all Muslims who are capable of carrying it out.

Accordingly none of my comments above apply to performing Umrah more than once. They are specifically directed at performing Hajj more than once.

Instead of going on Hajj a second time, I believe it would better for you to donate the money you would have spent to enable a poor person to perform Hajj.

 

The Disqus comments facility below allows you to comment on this page. Please respect others when commenting.
You can login using any of your Twitter, Facebook, Google+ or Disqus identities.
Even if you are not registered on any of these, you can still post a comment.
comments powered by Disqus

 

Custom Search

Follow @Mohammed_Amin

Tap for top of page